In Re: M/s. Signature International Foods India Private Limited
GST
2018 (12) TMI 892 – AUTHORITY FOR ADVANCE RULING, MAHARASHTRA – 2019 (20) G. S. T. L. 640 (A. A. R. – GST)
AUTHORITY FOR ADVANCE RULING, MAHARASHTRA – AAR
Dated:- 20-8-2018
GST-ARA-26/2018-19/B-91
GST
SHRI B.V. BORHADE, AND SHRI PANKAJ KUMAR, MEMBER
PROCEEDINGS
(Under section 98 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 and the Maharashtra Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017)
The present application has been filed under section 97 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 and the Maharashtra Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 [hereinafter referred to as “the CGST Act and MGST Act”] by Signature International Foods India Private Limited, the applicant, seeking an advance ruling in respect of the following questions.
1. “Whether on facts and circumstances of the case, the Unleavened Flatbreads be treated as 'Khakra, plain chapatti or roti under Entry No. 99A of Schedule / of Notification
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
r infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905]on a totally defatted basis not elsewhere specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905) under Entry No, 13 of Schedule III of Rate Notification or
(iii) Any other Schedule Entry as per Rate Notification or Exemption Notification as your good office thinks fit.
2. “Whether on facts and circumstances of the case, the Leavened Flatbreads be treated as 'as 'bread' as mentioned under Entry No. 97 of Exemption Notifications
If not, whether on facts and circumstances of the case, the Leavened Flatbreads be classified:
(i) Pizza Bread as mentioned under Entry No. 99 of Schedule of Rate Notifications; or
(ii) as Malt extract, food preparations of flour, groats, meal, starch or malt extract not containing coca or containing less than 40
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
t, food preparations of flour, groats, meal, starch or malt extract not containing coca or containing less than 40% by weight of coca calculated on a totally defatted basis, not elsewhere specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905]on a totally defatted basis not elsewhere specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905)” under Entry No. 13 of Schedule III of Rate Notification; or
(ii) Any other Schedule Entry as per Rate Notification or Exemption Notification as your good office thinks fit
4. “Whether on facts and circumstances of the case, Pancakes supplied be treated as All Goods i.e. Waffles and wafers other than coated with chocolate or containing chocolate; biscuits; Pastries and cakes (other than pizza bread, khakhra, plai
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
eference to the same provision under the MGST Act. Further to the earlier, henceforth for the purposes of this Advance Ruling, a reference to such a similar provision under the CGST Act / MGST Act would be mentioned as being under the “GST Act”
FACTS AND CONTENTION – AS PER THE APPLICANT
The submissions, as reproduced verbatim, could be seen thus-
Statement of the relevant facts having a bearing on the aforesaid question/(s)
The relevant facts of the case are as follows
1. Background of operations
1.1. The Applicant, a private limited company incorporated under the provisions of Companies Act, 1956 holding the CST registration number ('GSTIN') 27AACCH2133E123 with effect from 01 July 2017, is located at A/2, Plot No. 245, Shree Samarth Sahkari Audhyogik Vasahat, Mukhed Road, Pimpalgaon Baswant, Taluka Niphad, Nashik, Maharashtra.
1.2. The company is engaged in the business of, inter alia, manufacturing, trading and exporting bakery products which includes flatbreads.
1.3. The p
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
gar, baking powder, wheat gluten etc. The bakery process can be defined as a succession of steps that ensure the proper transformation of basic ingredients into unleavened breads. The baking processes the Applicant uses follow the same basic steps as traditional baking processes used for thousands of years.
1.7. The products are manufactured by the Applicant using various ingredients including atta, maida, water, palmolein oil, salt, sugar, baking powder, wheat gluten etc. Upon raw material intake, the ingredients go through various processes including mixing, proofing, dough dividing, baking and cooling. After the cooling process, the bread is packed, the packet is labelled and subsequently stored and transported at -18 Degree Celsius temperature or transported ambient. We have attached herewith the manufacturing process flow as Exhibit 1.
Leavened Flatbread information ('Bread Products')
1.8. The Applicant has been engaged in manufacturing and supplying leavened flatbreads includi
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
maida, tandoori attar atta, water, rice flour, oil, yeast, salt, sugar etc. Upon raw material intake, the ingredients go through various processes including mixing, proofing, dough dividing, baking and cooling, After the cooling process, the leavened bread is packed, the packet is labelled and subsequently stored and transported at -18 Degree Celsius temperature or transported ambient.
We have attached herewith the manufacturing process flow as Exhibit 1.
Wafer's information
1.12. The Applicant also manufactures and supplies Corn Chips, Corn Taco and Corn Taco Strips to its customers and distributors. It uses masa flour and water as the principal ingredients while manufacturing these products.
1.13. The products are manufactured by the Applicant using various ingredients including masa flour, water, small quantities of cellulose gum, citric acid, guar gum etc. upon raw material intake, the ingredients go through various processes including mixing, dough dividing, baking and cooling
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
ted at – 18 Degree Celsius temperature. These products are similar to cakes included in entry number 16 of Schedule III to the Rate Notifications.
We have attached herewith the manufacturing process flow as Exhibit 1.
Pizza bread information
1.17. The Applicant manufactures and supplies Pizza bread which is also called Pizza base. The products are manufactured by the Applicant using various ingredients including flour, water, sugar, salt, baking powder, yeast, oil etc. Upon raw material intake, the ingredients go through various processes including mixing, proofing, dough dividing, baking and cooling. After the cooling process, the pizza bread is packed and labelled and subsequently stored and transported at- 18 Degree Celsius temperature.
We have attached herewith the manufacturing process flow as Exhibit I.
Questions before AAR
2.1. The Applicant has approached the Hon'ble authority to determine the classification of
* Unleavened Flatbreads such as Plain Chapatti, Tortilla, T
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
containing chocolate, papad, bread]
Pancake
Entry No. 16 of Schedule III
All goods i.e. Waffles and wafers other than coated with chocolate or containing chocolate; biscuits; Pastries and cakes (other than pizza bread, khakhra, plain chapatti or roti, Waffles and wafers coated with chocolate or containing chocolate, papad, bread]
Pizza Bread
Entry No. 99 of Schedule I
Pizza Bread
2. 3. The Applicant, being desirous of ascertaining the classification of the bakery products supplied, wishes to submit this application before the Hon'ble Authority of Advance Ruling.
2.4. The Applicant reserves the right to submit such further facts at or before the hearing of the application as may be relevant.
Statement containing the Applicant's interpretation of classification in respect of the aforementioned question/(s) (refer Form ARA-01)
The Applicant prefers to present the application before this Hon'ble Authority on the following, among other grounds, each of which is ta
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
'Exemption Notifications'); or
(ii) as Malt extract, food preparations of flour, groats, meal, starch or malt extract not containing coca or containing less than 40% by weight of coca calculated on a totally defatted basis, not elsewhere specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905] on a totally defatted basis not elsewhere specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905) under Entry No. 13 of Schedule III of Rate Notification or
(iii) Any other Schedule Entry as per Rate Notification or Exemption Notification as your good office thinks fit.
Applicant's facts and interpretation of law
1.1. The Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance, has issued a notification number 01/2017-CentraI Tax (Rate) dated 28 June 2017 providing ta
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
first schedule to the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (51 of 1975).
Reference to Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (51 of 1975)
1.3. It is now pertinent to understand the clarification provided under the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 with respect to Heading 1905. The relevant entry is attached herewith as Exhibit 2. The said chapter 19 does not provide any clarification with respect to these terms in form of chapter notes, heading notes. Thus, the said term 'Kharkhra, Plain Chapatti or Roti' would need to be understood as known in common parlance.
Meaning of the term 'Khakhra, Plain Chapatti or Roti'
1.4. Given the fact that the terminology 'Khakhra, Plain Chapatti or Roti' are region specific terms, the dictionary meaning of the same is not available. Thus, we would need to refer to Wikipedial to understand the meaning of the same.
(i) Khakhra:
'a thin cracker, made from mat bean, wheat flour and oil'.
(ii) Plain Chapatti: 'an unleavened flatbread, made from whole of flour known as atta salt and w
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
unleavened flatbreads the Applicant produces.
1.7. In the light of the above discussion, we wish to mention that the ingredients used and the processes followed while manufacturing the unleavened flatbreads and Plain Chapatti or Roti are similar. Thus, the Applicant is of the belief that the range of unleavened flatbreads should to be classified under Entry No. 99A of Schedule of Rate Notification as 'Khakra, Plain Chapatti or Roti' and be leviable to GST accordingly.
Common and Commercial Parlance Theory
1.8. Without prejudice to the above submission, the applicant wishes to submit that it is a settled position under common law that in the absence of a statutory definition, a word is to be interpreted by understanding its meaning under the common parlance. This position has been upheld by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of M/s. United Offset Process Pvt. Ltd. V ACC, Bombay & Ors. (1989 Supp.(1) SCC 131] = 1988 (10) TMI 39 – SUPREME COURT OF INDIA. The Apex Court commented:
I
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
* No meaning has been attributed in the statute
* There is an open market for such goods
The above position has been succinctly encapsulated by the Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the case of Pharm Aromatic Chemicals v MCGM (1997 (95) ELT 203 Bom) = 1994 (2) TMI 320 – BOMBAY HIGH COURT. The Bombay High Court commented:
Various principles or tests have been evolved by the Supreme Court from time to time for interpretation of items of taxable goods. One of the well-known principles of interpretation is that words of everyday use must be construed not in the scientific or technical sense but as understood in the common parlance
1.10. Another test akin to the common parlance test is the “commercial parlance test”. According to this test, items in taxing statutes should be judged and analysed on the basis of how these expressions are used in the trade or industry or in the market or, in other words how these are dealt with by the people who deal in them. Though the common parlance or com
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
tionally in different countries as Tortilla, Tortilla Wraps, Wraps, Roti Rolls, Roti, Chapatti, Paratha and Paratha Wraps.
1.13. Basis the above, we wish to further submit that the Applicant has been receiving various order for the above mentioned food items referred to it as Chapatti, Tortilla etc. We wish to further submit that these unleavened flatbreads are generally being used in different regions across the country. Thus, the commercial name for these unleavened flatbreads may vary depending upon the region where the supply is intended. However, we have attached herewith the purchase orders raised by various customers depicting the name usually followed in the industry as Exhibit
1.14. On the basis of the above discussion, it is humbly submitted that the above mentioned unleavened flatbreads manufactured and supplied by the Applicant are either known as Plain Chapatti or Roti' in commercial parlance as well. Thus, the same should be leviable to GST accordingly
End-user test
1
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
plain chapatti, roti or variants of these type of unleavened flatbreads as the staple underlying carrier in one's meal. It is usually accompanied by protein or vegetables and sauce.
1.17. In the light of above mentioned discussion and given the fact that the Applicant uses similar ingredients and processes as those used for manufacturing Chapatti or Roti, the Applicant strongly believes that the range of unleavened flatbreads manufactured and supplied by them should be classified as 'Plain Chapatti or Roti' and should accordingly be levied to GST.
1.18. Without prejudice to the above mentioned submission, in case the unleavened flatbreads manufactured by the Applicant does not qualify as 'Plain Chapatti or Roti' within the meaning of Rate Notification, we request your good office to provide ruling on its possible alternate classification under below mentioned entry considering the facts and circumstances of the case.
(i) Entry No. 97 of Exemption Notification, which stands for Brea
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
vened Flatbreads be treated as 'as bread' as mentioned under Entry No. 97 of Exemption Notifications If not, whether on facts and circumstances of the case, the Leavened Flatbreads be classified:
(i) Pizza Bread as mentioned under Entry No. 99 of Schedule / of Rate Notifications; or
(ii) as Malt extract, food preparations of flour, groats, meal, starch or malt extract not containing coca or containing less than 40% by weight of coca calculated on a totally defatted basis, not elsewhere specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905]on a totally defatted basis not elsewhere specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905) under Entry No. 13 of Schedule III of Rate Notification or
(iii) Any other Schedule Entry as per Rate Notific
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
that the tariff item, subheading, heading and chapter shall mean respectively a tariff item, sub-heading, heading and chapter as specified in the first schedule to the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (51 of 1975).
Reference to Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (51 of 1975)
It is now pertinent to understand the clarification provided under the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 with respect to Heading 1905. The relevant entry is attached herewith as Exhibit 2. The said chapter 19 does not provide any clarification with respect to these terms in form of chapter notes, heading notes. Thus, the said term 'leavened bread would need to be understood as known in common parlance.
Dictionary meaning of the term 'bread'
2.4. The Webster Dictionary has defined the term 'bread' as a usually baked and leavened food made of a mixture whose basic constituent is flour or meal. The definition basically consists of two parts, one process of making bread ie. Baked and leavened and other is ingredient used while manufacturing
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
during manufacturing process for each of the leavened flatbreads.
2.7. In the light of the above discussion, we wish to mention that the ingredients used and the processes followed while manufacturing the leavened flatbreads and bread are similar. Thus, the Applicant is of the belief that the range of leavened flatbreads should to be classified as 'bread' and be exempted from GST.
Common and Commercial Parlance Theory
2.8. Without prejudice to above submission, the applicant wishes to submit that it is a settled position under common law that in the absence of a statutory definition, a word is to be interpreted by understanding its meaning under the common parlance. This position has been upheld by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of M/s. United Offset Process Pvt. Ltd. V ACC, Bombay & Ors. (1989 Supp.(1) SCC 131] = 1988 (10) TMI 39 – SUPREME COURT OF INDIA. The Apex Court commented:
If there is no meaning attributed to the expressions used in the particular enacted statute t
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
e above position has been succinctly encapsulated by the Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the case of Pharm Aromatic Chemicals v MCGM (1997 (95) ELT 203 Bom) = 1994 (2) TMI 320 – BOMBAY HIGH COURT. The Bombay High Court commented'.
Various principles or tests have been evolved by the Supreme Court from time to time for interpretation of items of taxable goods. One of the well-known principles of interpretation is that words of everyday use must be construed not in the scientific or technical sense but as understood in the common parlance
2.10. Another test akin to the common parlance test is the “commercial parlance test”. According to this test, items in taxing statutes should be judged and analysed on the basis of how these expressions are used in the trade or industry or in the market or, in other words how these are dealt with by the people who deal in them. Though the common parlance or commercial parlance tests are the generally accepted tests, various other tests have been evolved
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
lded Leavened Flatbread.
2.13. Basis the above, we wish to further submit that the Applicant has been receiving various order for the above mentioned food items referred to it as Naan, Kulcha, etc. We wish to further submit that these leavened flatbreads are generally being used in various regions across the country and are regularly referred to it as bread. Thus, the commercial name for these leavened flatbreads may vary depending upon region where the supply is intended.
2.14. On the basis of the above discussion, it is humbly submitted that the above mentioned food items manufactured and supplied by the Applicant are known as 'bread' in commercial parlance as well. Thus, the same should be exempted from GST.
Leavened flatbreads not served for consumption
2.15. The Schedule Entry No. 97 of Exemption Notification refer to the breads (branded or otherwise) except when served for consumption. Further, the meaning of the word “served for consumption” is not defined anywhere including
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
restaurant including any eating house, hotel, refreshment room or boarding establishment or any part thereof which is large or in any club or by a caterer or when sold under a registered trade mark”
C-11-15:” Food and the alcoholic drinks 'served for consumption' in any eating house, restaurant, hotel refreshment room or boarding establishment or any part thereof having gradation of the four Star any above or supply by such eating house, restaurant, hotel, refreshment room or boarding establishment”
Given the above, the tribunal held that exemption of sales tax on the sale of bread is subject to the condition that it will be tax free except when it is served for consumption in public restaurant including eating house, hotel, refreshment room etc. The Tribunal stated that as bread is sold from the shop as counter sale there is no service of bread for consumption in Five Star Hotel or in any part thereof. Hence it is covered by schedule entry A-4 and not by schedule entry C-14-15.
2.
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
f Rate Notification, which stands for Malt extract, food preparations of flour, groats, meal, starch or malt extract not containing coca or containing less than 40% by weight of coca calculated on a totally defatted basis, not elsewhere specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905]on a totally defatted basis not elsewhere specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905); or
(iii) Any other Schedule Entry as per Rate Notification or Exemption Notification as your good office thinks fit.
Applicants interpretation of facts or law with regards to Question No. 3
“Whether on facts and circumstances of the case, Corn Chips, Corn Taco and Corn Taco Strips supplied be treated as Wafers under Entry No. 16 of Schedule III of Rate Notificatio
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
Revenue, Ministry of Finance, has issued a notification number 01/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28 June 2017 providing exemptions on intra-state supplies of goods, the description of which is specified in the schedule appended to the said notification from the whole of the central tax leviable thereon under the section 9 of Central Goods and Service Tax Act, 2017 (12 of 2017). Similar notifications have been issued under Integrated Goods and Service Tax Act, 2017 and Maharashtra Goods and Service Tax Act, 2017.
3.2 The Schedule Entry No. 16 of Schedule III of the Rate Notifications refers to 'All goods ie. Waffles and wafers other than coated with chocolate or containing chocolate falling under Chapter 1905 32 90 (i.e. not containing chocolate). The said notification does not define the term 'wafer'. However, it is mentioned that the tariff item, sub-heading, heading and chapter shall mean respectively a tariff item, sub-heading, heading and chapter as specified in the first schedule
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
mixing, dough dividing, baking and cooling. After the cooling process, the products are packed and labelled and subsequently stored and transported at -18 Degree Celsius temperature.
3.5 In case of supply of Corn Chips, Corn Taco and Corn Taco Strips, we wish to bring to your kind attention that the process of making such products involves both baking as well as the use of masa flour, water, small quantities of cellulose gum, citric acid, guar gum etc. Further, customers in the foodservice channel and, in some cases, the end consumer fry the products which makes them cripsy similar to products such as wafers, i.e. a thin crisp cracker.
3.6 Hence, it can be concluded that Corn Chips, Corn Taco and Corn Taco Strips are classifiable under entry number 16 of Schedule III of the Rate Notification.
Common and Commercial Parlance Theory
3.7 Without prejudice to above submission, we wish to reiterate our submission with respect to common and commercial parlance theory made under applicant
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
sense rule of interpretation”
3.10 In the present instance, 'wafers' are not defined in the Customs Tariff Act, 1975. Further, there is a common market for trade in such goods. Hence, the present instance is a fit case for usage of the common parlance test.
3.11 It is humbly submitted that in the Indian context, wafers refers to chips used as a snack. In fact, wafers and chips terminology are used interchangeably. Further, post the supply by applicant, customers in the foodservice channel and, in some cases, the end consumer fry the products which makes them crispy similar to products such as wafers, i.e. a thin crisp cracker. In addition, some customers add various spices and condiments to the products and pack them in smaller pack sizes for the retail market.
3.12 Corn Chips, Corn Taco and Corn Taco Strips are variants of chips eaten as a snack. In any big department store, Corn Chips, Corn Taco and Corn Taco Strips are normally sold in the section dealing with wafers and such sna
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
Chapter 1905 32 90 subject to GST accordingly.
Contextual interpretation
3.18 Snacks such as Corn Chips, Corn Taco and Corn Taco Strips are seen as an alternative to potato chips, cream wafers, etc. Corn Chips, Corn Taco and Corn Taco Strips are becoming popular amongst consumers with the increasing demand for alternative varieties of wafers and snacking food items.
3.19. Hence, considering the context surrounding such products, it should be concluded that they are similar to wafers falling under Chapter 1905 32 90 subject to tax accordingly.
3.20 Without prejudice to the above mentioned submission, in case the Corn Chips, Corn Taco and Corn Taco Strips manufactured by the Applicant does not classify as 'wafer' within the meaning of emption Notification, we request your good office to provide ruling on its possible alternate classification under
(i) Entry No. 13 of Schedule III of Rate Notification, which stands for Malt extract, food preparations of flour, groats, meal, starch or
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
and wafers coated with chocolate or containing chocolate, papad, bread] as mentioned under Entry No. 16 of Schedule III of Rate Notifications.
If not, whether on facts and circumstances of the case, the Pancakes be classified any other Schedule Entry as per Rate Notification or Exemption Notification as your good office thinks
Applicant's interpretation of law or facts
4.1 Basis the plain reading of Rate Notification, the Applicant believes that the Pancake should get classified under the entry number 16 of Schedule III of the Rate Notifications which stands for 'All goods ie. Waffles and Wafers other than coated with coated with chocolate or containing chocolate; biscuits; Pastries and cakes (other than pizza bread, khakhra, plain chapatti or roti, Waffles and wafers coated with chocolate or containing chocolate, papad, bread).
4.2 The term 'cake' has not been defined in the Rate Notification. However, it is mentioned that the tariff item, sub-heading, heading and chapter shall me
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
etc. Upon raw material intake, the ingredients go through various processes including mixing, dough dividing, baking on a hot plate on both sides and cooling- After the cooling process, the pancake is packed and labelled and subsequently stored and transported at – 18 Degree Celsius temperature.
Basically, it is a flat cake, often thin and round, prepared from a starch based batter and is cooked on a hot surface such as griddle or frying pan. It may be served at any time of the day with the variety of the topping or fillings including jam, fruit, syrup or ice cream.
Common and Commercial Parlance Theory
4.7 Without prejudice to above submission, we wish to reiterate our submission with respect to common and commercial parlance theory made under applicants interpretation of fact and law of Question 1.
4.8 Even in common parlance, Pancakes are known as 'cakes' in the hotel industry. Thus, the Applicant strongly believes that the same gets covered under Entry Number 16 of Schedule III
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
get classified under the entry number 99 of Schedule / of the Rate Notifications
5.2 The term 'Pizza Bread' has not been defined in the Rate Notification. However, it is mentioned that the tariff item, sub-heading, heading and chapter shall mean respectively a tariff item, sub-heading, heading and chapter as specified in the first schedule to the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (51 of 1975).
5.3 The products are manufactured by the Applicant using various ingredients including flour, water, sugar, salt, baking powder, yeast, vegetable oil etc. Upon raw material intake, the ingredients go through various processes including mixing, proofing, dough dividing, baking and cooling. After the cooling process, the pizza bread is packed and labelled and subsequently stored and transported at -18 Degree Celsius temperature.
Reference to Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (51 of 1975)
5.4 It is now pertinent to understand the clarification as provided under the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 to understand the mean
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
, the Applicant submits that entry number 99 of Schedule I to the Rate Notifications should apply and GST to be levied accordingly.
5.7 Without prejudice to the above mentioned submission, in case the product manufactured by the Applicant does not qualify as 'pizza bread' within the meaning of Rate Notification, we request your good office to provide ruling on its possible alternate classification any other Schedule Entry as per Rate Notification or Exemption Notification as your good office thinks.
Further to above submissions, we most respectfully request that:
* Allow us to reiterate all the submissions without prejudice to one another;
* Grant a personal hearing put forth our contentions and explain our submissions before passing any order in this regard;
* Allow us to amend, alter and add to the present reply;
* Allow us to produce additional documents and other material during the time of Personal Hearing;
* In case the classification and rate argued by the Applicant
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
redients
1.
Maida – High Protein
1.
Maida
2.
Water
2.
Water
3.
Glycerine
3.
Palmolein Oil
4.
Wheat Gluten
4.
Glycerine
5.
Salt
5.
L-Cysterine
6.
Sugar
6.
Sodium Bi Carbonate
7.
Yeast
7.
Salt
8.
Baking Powder
8.
Powerflex
9.
Kalonji Seed
9.
Dimodaan
10.
Hydroxypropyl Methyl Cellulose
10.
Sugar
11.
Ultrasoft
11.
Sodium Acid Pyro Phosphate
12.
Calcium Propionate
12.
Acecol Gaur Gum
13.
Kalonaji Oil
13.
Calcium Propionate
14.
Fumaric Acid
15.
Grindsted Protex
Unleavened Flatbread-Chapati
Leavened Flatbread-Chalupa
S. No.
Ingredients
S. No.
Ingredients
1.
Atta
1.
Maida
2.
Water
2.
Sunflower Oil
3.
Palmolein Oil
3.
Water
4.
Wheat Gluten
4.
Rice Flour
5.
Salt
5.
TBBI
6.
Dimodaan Hp-1
6.
Yeast
7.
Sugar
7.
Salt
8.
Baking Powder
8.
Su
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
ing Agent
9.
Milk
10.
Yeast
10.
Sunflower Oil
11.
Acidity regulator
11.
Golden Syrup
12.
Preservative
12.
Vanilla Flavor
13.
Thickener
13.
Whey Powder
14.
Flour treatment agent
14.
Detam
List of Ingredients Leavened Flatbread-Pita Bread
Corn Taco
S. No.
Ingredients
S. No.
Ingredients
1.
Tandoori Atta
1.
Masa flour
2.
Atta
2.
Water
3.
Water
3.
Cal. Prop
4.
Wheat Gluten
4.
Citric Acid
5.
Salt
5.
Cellulose Gum
6.
Yeast
6.
Guar Gum
Leavened Flatbread-Chalupa
Leavened Flatbread-Kulcha
S. No.
Ingredients
S. No.
Ingredients
1.
Maida
1.
Maida
2.
Sunflower Oil
2.
Vinegar
3.
Water
3.
Water
4.
Rice Flour
4.
Sugar
5.
TBBI
5.
Salt
6.
Yeast
6.
Yeast
7.
Salt
7.
Baking Powder
8.
Sugar
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
@ <-18 C
Dispatch
PROCESS FLOW DIAGRAM (PANCAKE)
Raw Material Intake
Raw Material Storage
Premixing and sieving
Mixing
Oven Bake
Online Cooling @ < 24C
Online inspection
Stacking
Packaging
Metal Detection
CCP
Spiral blast Freezing @ -30 to 35 C
Packaging
Collection to pellets
Finished Goods Storage-Cold Room @ <-18 C
Dispatch
Additional submission to Advance Ruling application submitted by applicant on 23 May 2018
We, Signature International Foods India Private Limited (the "Applicant" or "Company") a private limited company incorporated under the provisions of the Companies Act, 1956 holding GST registration number 27AACCH2133E1Z3, have filed an advance ruling application on 23 May 2018 for the classification of products manufactured by and supplied by the Company.
In this connection, we have attended a personal h earing for the acceptanc
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
o CGST and MGST at 9% each;
d. Naan to be classified under residual entry considering the fact that it is used as a Roti, eaten with curry in South East Asia and leviable to CGST and MGST at 9% each;
e. Pita Bread and Kulcha to be classified under residual entry considering that these products are ready for consumption and leviable to CGST and MGST at 9% each;
f. Corn Chips, Corn Taco, Corn Taco Strips shall be classified under Entry No. 16 of Schedule III of the Rate n leviable to tax at CGST and MGST at 9% each;
g. Pancake qualify as cake within the meaning of rate notification classifying the product under Entry No. 16 of Schedule III under Chapter heading 1905; and
h. Pizza Bread qualify as Pizza Bread under Entry No. 99 of Schedule l.
i. At the outset, the Applicant most respectfully wishes to submit that the letter has been prepared without giving due regards to all the facts of the case and the submissions made by the Company till date. The Applicant has provided a deta
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
tbreads such as leavened flatbreads and unfolded leavened flatbreads.
Without prejudice to submissions made in the advance ruling application, the Applicant wishes to make an additional submission providing a responses to the views provided by the learned Nodal Officer on variants of unleavened flatbreads and all types of leavened flatbreads. It shall be noted that this additional submission shall be considered to be in addition to submissions made in advance ruling application.
Applicants additional submissions
1. Applicants response to classification of some variants of unleavened flatbreads such as Roti Rolls, Paratha and Paratha Rolls
1.1 The Applicant wishes to submit that learned Nodal Officer has not considered ingredients and the manufacturing processes used while manufacturing unleavened flatbreads. In the letter, it was mentioned that
(i) the food stuff such as Paratha, Paratha Rolls, Roti Rolls shall be classified as per the common parlance test as laid down by the Hon'
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
by the courts is the user test. According to this test the use to which the goods can be put can also be considered in interpreting an item. The copy of relevant judicial precedence has already been submitted with your office. A copy of the same is again enclosed as Annexure 1.
1.4 By applying Common parlance Test and End User Test, we wish to humbly submit that many types of unleavened flatbreads including plain chapatti, roti and variants of these types of unleavened flatbreads are a staple underlying carrier in one's meal. It is usually accompanied by protein or vegetables and sauce.
Considering the same, it is clear that the usage or function of such as Roti Rolls, Paratha, Paratha Rolls, Tortilla Wraps, Tortilla, Wraps, Paratha Wraps are the same or similar to Plain Chapatti or Roti.
1.5 At this juncture, it is also important to note the ruling of the Apex Court of India in the case of M/s. O K Play (India) Limited V. Commissioner of Central Excise, Delhi-III, Gurgaon = 2005 (2
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
, which is also relevant in the underlying case. In food industry, various types of unleavened flatbreads are called different names by different users depending upon the regions where the food is served or consumed. variants of Chapatti flatbreads are referred to internationally in different countries as Tortilla, Tortilla Wraps, Wraps, Roti Rolls, Roti, Chapatti, Paratha and Paratha Wraps. Therefore, it is imperative that one shall give due regards to End User Test also. Considering the same, we wish to reiterate the fact that various types of unleavened flatbreads like those mentioned in the application are being used in one's daily meal accompanied by protein or vegetables and sauce and hence, shall be classified as Plain Chapatti or Roti.
Ingredient Test
2. the learned Nodal Officer has further mentioned that the ingredients used for variants of unleavened flatbreads such as Roti Rolls, Paratha and Paratha Rolls are different than Plain Roti or Roti as mentioned under Entry No.
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
h to bring to your notice that many variants of unleavened flatbreads are considered to be the same or similar as Plain Chapatti or Roti because these bakery products act as a near substitute to each other as a carrier for a meal. Thus, the Applicant strongly believes that the same shall be classified as 'Plain Chapatti or Roti' under Entry No, 99A of Rate Notification.
Manufacturing process Test
5. The learned Nodal Officer has further mentioned that the manufacturing process of unleavened flatbreads such as Roti Rolls, Paratha and Paratha Rolls are different than Plain Roti or Roti. In this regard, we wish to mention that the Applicant has already submitted manufacturing flow charts in respect of all variants of unleavened flatbread in its original application.
6. The range of unleavened flatbreads manufactured by the Company, including Roti, Roti Rolls, Paratha, Tortilla, Tortilla Wraps and Wraps are produced on the same production line using the same or similar production method
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
d
2.1 We wish to re-submit that learned Nodal Officer has not considered ingredients and the manufacturing processes used while manufacturing leavened flatbreads.
In the letter, it was mentioned that:
Sr.No.
Name of Leavened flatbread
Learned Nodal officer's relevant contentions
1.
Chalupta
1. Traditional Chalupa are small. thick, boat shaped fried maza topped only with cheese and shredded lettua
2. These are filled with various ingredients such as chicken, pork, chopped onion etc.
3: In view of the manufacturing process and type of ingredients used in it, the same cannot be classified under Entry No. 97 of Exemption Notification. Hence, the same shall be covered under residual entry
2.
Naan
1. Naan cannot fall under Entry No. 97 of Exemption Notification as it is commonly used as a Roti in South Asia Region
2. By applying common parlance test, common man cannot say Naan as Bread
3. It is used as a Roti eaten with curry in South East Asia
4. Accordingly, the same canno
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
e construed as a food which is ready to eat. The Schedule Entry No. 97 refers to bread except when served for immediate consumption. However, it is clear that 'ready to serve' means ready to eat'. There is no distinction between them Food is not necessarily served only in Hotel. Food is also served at home. Hence, dealers contention regarding served for immediate consumption is misinterpretation of the term”
2.3. Basis the review of the submissions of learned Nodal Officer, we wish to submit that the learned Nodal Officer has made classification on the basis of:
a. Common Parlance Test;
b. Ingredient Test; and
c. Manufacturing process Test.
2.4. At the outset, we wish to reiterate our submissions made in the application for advance ruling from Para 2.1 till Para 2.18 in Annexure III wherein we have provided our submissions with respect to applicability of exemption in respect of all variants of leavened flatbreads considering above mentioned tests. We have provided below our addit
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
s maida, sunflower oil, water, rice flour, yeast, salt, sugar, gluten and TBBI.
2.7. Referring to the learned Nodal Officer's contention on the usage of additional ingredients such as Ch icken, Pork etc., we would like to submit that the Applicant supplies the Chalupa bread flat, unfolded in the base form. The customer receives the bread from the Company frozen at -18*c and the customer subsequently defrosts the bread. After this the customer fries the bread using a U-shaped fryer mold. It is this U-shape fryer mould that gives the Chalupa the U shape which is sometimes referred to as a boat shape. The Chalupa gets the crispy texture and is heated up when the customer fries the product. After this the customer can include their own sauce, filling, protein and vegetables in the bread before serving the final product to the end consumer. Thus, the said contention will not hold good factually.
2.8. Additionally, the Applicant follows the same or similar manufacturing processes as those
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
2.11. In fact, it shall be observed that they have given utmost importance to the 'End User Test' while determining the classification of Naan. The Applicant believes that the customer and end consumer considers naan to be a bread. This point is strongly supported by the fact that naan is included under the heading of Bread or Indian Breads on the menu cards of many restaurants across India and internationally.
2.12. The range of leavened flatbreads manufactured by the Company, including naan, are produced on the same production line using the same or similar production methods and processes. The flow chart included in the original application shows that the Applicant follows the same or similar processes for all variants of leavened flatbreads. Upon raw material intake, the ingredients go through various processes including mixing, proofing, dough dividing, baking and cooling. After the cooling process, the leavened flatbread is packed and labelled and subsequently stored and transp
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
ead and Kulcha
2.15. While providing views on the availability of exemption to Pita Bread and Kulcha, the learned Nodal Officer has mentioned that the Applicant has himself applied tax rate of 2.5% in the invoices raised by them. However, these products could not be classified under Entry No. 97 of the Exemption Notification. Pita Bread and Kulcha cannot be treated as bread.
2.16. In this regard, we wish to mention that the Applicant has submitted an intimation letter with the Central Tax authorities on 20 July 2017 inti mating that payment of Central Tax, State Tax and Integrated Tax under protest, in the absence of specific schedule entry with respect to product being manufactured and supplied by the Applicant.
2.17. Moreover, the Applicant has discharged GST liability for leavened flatbread to the extent of 2.5% of CGST and MGST on a conservative basis.
Leavened flatbreads not served for immediate consumption
2.18. While denying the exemption under Entry No. 97 of Exemption Not
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
efrosting, addition of toppings and heating which is carried out before serving for consumption to the end consumer or customer.
2.20. The majority of the products supplied the Company are supplied frozen at a temperature of -18*c. It is not possible for the customer or end consumer to eat the product when they receive it at -18*c for a number of reasons. The first reason is that the bread is very hard when it is in a frozen state and the person trying to eat the frozen product could damage their teeth if they try to bite into the frozen product. Frozen bread can be very brittle and there is a risk that the bread breaks into pieces if someone tries to eat it. The bread would not be functional as a carrier in its frozen state. In addition, frozen bread does not taste good. The points above are relevant if the bread is bought by a customer in the foodservice channel such as hotels and restaurants or if the frozen bread is consumed in the home. Therefore, the breads that the Company supp
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
ariants of leavened flatbreads. In case your office differs With the Applicant's view of exemption, we wish to submit that leavened flatbreads can also be treated at par with pizza Bread after considering manufacturing process test and ingredient test.
9. Request:
In the light of above additional submissions, we wish to put forth our contentions below:
* Classification of products as per submissions made in the application of advance ruling
* Treat this submissions as the statement of responses to the submissions made by the learned Nodal Officer
In case classification of leavened flatbread is not acceptable to your office, request you to consider the request of treating it as 'Pizza Bread' after giving due regard to the manufacturing test and ingredient test. Should your office require any additional information / documentation in order to enable your office to arrive at a final conclusion, we shall be glad to furnish the same,
03. CONTENTION – AS PER THE CONCERNED OFFICER
Th
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
facturing of Unleavened flat breads like Roti, Chappati, Paratha, Paratha wraps, Tortilla, Tortilla wraps, Roti Rolls, etc.
1) Dealer has clarified his product i.e. Unleavened flat breads schedule entry 99 (A) as “Khakhra, pain chappati or roti” so far as Indian food stuffs like Roti, Plain Roti is concerned it can be clarified under Tariff heading 2016 under entry 99 (A) and should be taxed at CGST 2.5% and SGST 2.5%.
But the food stuffs like Paratha wraps, Paratha, Roti rolls cannot clarified in above mentioned entry i.e. entry 99 (A) because as per Hon. Supreme Court guideline these should be common parlance test for determination of tax rate of particular commodity.
So if we apply this common parlance test to these Indian food stuffs like paratha, Paratha rolls, Roti Rolls, we can't identify these food products as plain Roti or Roti The manufacturing process and ingredients are different than that of plain Roti or Roti. Common man can't say Paratha or Roti Rolls as a plain Roti,
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
ered under residuary entry and taxable at 9% in CGST and MGST Act.
NaanA typical 'Naan' recipe involves mixing white flour with salt, a yeast culture and enough yogurt to make smooth, elastic enough. The dough is kneaded for few minutes. Then dough is divided into balls which are flattered and cooked. The 'Naan” can be said to be a 'Leavened Bread as that are made from natural leavened like yeast, yogurt and butter milk. So this product 'Naan' can't fall under entry 97 as it is commonly used as Roti in South Asia region. By applying common parlance test to this product, common man can't say 'Naan' as a bread. It is used as a Roti, eaten with curry in South East Asia. So in my opinion Naan cannot be held as leavened bread and treated as exempted product. In my opinion the food products i.e. Naan would be covered under residuary entry and taxable at 9% in CGST and MGST.
Pita bread and Kulcha -Pita bread & Kulcha are leavened bread. But dealer himself applied tax rate at 2.5% in the inv
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
at 9% CGST and 9% MGST Act. Corn Chips, Corn Taco, Corn Taco strips –
Dealer is manufactures of food products like corn chips, corn Taco, Corn Taco strips. Dealer has clarified these products under entry No. 16 of schedule III.
Dealer has rightly classified these products. In my opinion the food product like corn chips, Corn Taco & Corn Taco strips also fall under chapter heading 1905, Entry No.16 schedule III having tax rate @9% CGST & SGST.
Pancake -Pancake is flat cake, thin & round prepared from starch bared butter that contains eggs, milk, butter. Pancake are known as 'cakes'. In many opinion Pancake manufactured by the applicant qualify as 'cakes' within the meaning of Rate notification clarifying the product under entry 16 schedule Ill under chapter heading 1905.
Pizza Bread -Pizza Bread supplied by' the applicant is covered under entry No. 99 of schedule I. Dealer has rightly clarified the food product ie. Pizza Bread under entry No.99 of schedule I having tax rate @ 2.5%
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
e dealer seeks classification of tax rate in respect of following commodities.
I. Unleavened flat breads- Khakhra, plain chapatti, roti, paratha, paratha rolls and roti rolls
II. Leavened flat breads- Naan, kulcha, chalupa and pita bread
III. Corn chips, Corn Taco, Corn Taco strips.
IV. Pan cake.
V. Pizza bread,
I have gone through the submission of documents submitted by the dealer. I will discuss h item one by one and explain my opinion in this regard as below.
eavened flat breads – plicant's interpretationealer is engaged in manufacturing of Unleavened flat breads like Roti, Chappati, paratha, Paratha wraps, Tortilla, Tortilla wraps, Roti Rolls, etc. Dealer has classified this product i.e. Unleavened flat breads schedule entry no.99 (A) as “Khakhra, pain chappati or roti ”
Manufacturing process- (Chapatti, Roti, Khakhra, Paratha, Paratha rolls, Tortilla, Roti rolls)
Mixing
(Atta+ water+ palmolein oil+wheat gluten+salt+dimodaanHp-1+ sugar+ baking powder)
¯
Dough div
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
der Schedule- I entry no. 99(A) taxable at 2.5% in CGST and MGST.
II. Leavened flat bread –
* Applicant's interpretation-
* Dealer has treated leavened flat bread under Entry no, 97 of Exemption notification no.2/2017 Dt-28/06/2017 of CGST Act.
* Entry no.97 stands for “Bread (branded or otherwise) except when served for consumption and pizza bread.” Opinion of Jurisdiction Officer
* In Leavened flat breads such as Naan, Chalupa, Pita bread, Kulcha, unfold leavened flat breads are also manufactured & sold by the dealer.
A) Chalupa –
* A chalupa is speciality of south central Mexico. Traditional Chalupas are small, thick, boat shaped fried masa (maize) topped only with red salra(salad), green salra, chopped onion, cheese and shredded chicken. These are filled with various ingredients such as chicken, pork, chopped onion, etc. So in view of the manufacturing process and type of ingredient used in it, the Chalupa could not fall under Entry no-97 of Exemption notification. It c
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
are leavened bread. But dealer himself applied tax rate at 2.5% in the invoices raised by him. But these product could not be classified under entry no,97 as exempted goods. Pita bread and Kulcha cannot be termed as bread.
* So the products like Naan, Pita Bread, Kulcha, levened bread can be served for consumption. These food products are ready for consumption. They are not raw or unfinished form. Ready to serve foods should be construed as a fodd which is ready to eat.
* The schedule entry no. 97 of Exemption notification refer to breads except when served for consumption. Dealer has taken meaning of served for Consumption as in food served in hotel, restaurant etc. However it is clear that 'ready-to-serve' means ready-to-eat'. There is no distinction between 'ready-to-eat foods' and 'ready to serve foods'. Food is not necessarily served only in a Hotel. Food is also 'served in a home.
* Hence dealers contention regarding 'served for consumption' is misinterpretation of the term
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
sified these products. In my opinion the food product like corn chips, Corn Taco & Corn Taco strips also fall under chapter heading 1905, Entry No. 16 schedule III having tax rate @9% CGST & SGST.
IV. Pancake –
Applicant's interpretation-
Dealer has classified Pancake as a cake which is commonly known to everyone and treated the same under Entry no. 16 of Schedule-III of CGST Act.
Manufacturing process- (Pan cake)
Mixing
(Wheat flour+ water+ sugar+ salt+ sodium bicarbonate+ sodium acid pyrophosphate+ citric acid+ calcium propionate+ milk+ sunflower oil+ golden syrup + vanilla flavour + whey powder+ detam)
Baking in oven
¯
Online cooling @<24oc
¯
Online inspection (sorting)
¯
Metal detection
¯
Spiral blast freezing @-30 to 35c
¯
Packaging
¯
Collation to pallets
¯
Finished goods storage @<-18 C
¯
Dispatch in frozen vehicle@-18 C
Opinion of Jurisdiction Officer
Pancake is flat cake, thin & round prepared from starch bared bu
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
t breads
Schedule-III Entry no. 453 (A)
9% CGST 9% MGST
i) Naan, ii) Chalupa, iii) Pita Bread iv) Kulcha
3.
Corn chips, Corn Taco, Corn Taco Strips
Entry No. 16 Schedule III
9% CGST 9% MGST
4.
Pancake
Entry No. 16 Schedule III
9% CGST 9% MGST
5.
Pizza Bread
Entry No. 99 Schedule I
2.5% CGST 2.5% MGST
04. HEARING
The Preliminary hearing in the matter was held on 03.07.2018, Sh. Pratik Shah, C.A. along with Sh. Ramesh Warungare, Finance head appeared and requested for admission of application as per contentions made their ARA. Jurisdictional Officer Sh. M. R. Shinde, Asstt. Commissioner of State Tax (NAS-VAT-D-009) Nasik appeared and made written submissions.
The application was admitted and called for final hearing on 25.07.2018, Pratik Shah, C.A. along with Sh. Nitin Vijai vrgiya, C.A., Ms. Snehal Gadhave, C.A., Sh. Yatin Patel, Managing Director, Sh. ABHAY Mundra, C.A. and Sh. Ramesh Warungare, Finance Head appeared made oral and written submissions. Jurisdic
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
a and overseas. The details of manufacturing process and ingredients required are in short as thus,
A) Unleavened Flatbread includes Plain Chapatti and variants of Chapatti flatbreads referred to internationally in different countries as Tortilla, Tortilla Wraps, Wraps, Roti Rolls, Roti, Chapatti, Paratha and Paratha Wraps The products are manufactured by the Applicant using various ingredients including Atta, Maida, water, Palmolein oil, salt, sugar, baking powder, wheat gluten etc. Upon raw material intake, the ingredients go through various processes including mixing, proofing, dough dividing, baking and cooling. After the cooling process, the bread is packed, the packet is labelled and subsequently stored and transported at -18 Degree Celsius temperature or transported ambient.
B) Leavened Flatbread includes ('Bread Products') Naan, Kulcha and variants of these type of leavened breads referred to internationally in different countries as Pitta bread, Chalupa, Corn bread, Leavened
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
ntly stored and transported at -18 Degree Celsius temperature. Upon receipt of these products, the customer or end consumer fries the product, which is similar to products such as wafers.
D) Pancake's includes – 'pancakes', a flat cake, often thin and round, prepared from a starch-based batter that may contain milk baked on a hot surface such as a griddle or frying pan. The pancakes manufactured by using of ingredients like wheat flour, water, sugar, salt, milk, syrup, oil etc. Upon raw material intake, the ingredients go through various processes including mixing, dough dividing, baking on a hot plate on both sides and cooling. After the cooling process, the pancake is packed and labelled and subsequently stored and transported at – 18 Degree Celsius temperature. These products are similar to cakes included in entry number 16 of Schedule III to the Rate Notifications.
E) Pizza bread includes Pizza bread which is also called Pizza base. The products are manufactured by the Applicant
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
n facts and circumstances of the case, the Unleavened Flatbreads be treated as Khakra, plain chapatti or roti under Entry No. 99 A of Schedule / of Notification No. 01/2017-Integrated Tax (Rate) dated 28 June 2017, Notification Number 1/2017-Central Tax (Rate), dated 28 June 2017 and Notification Number 1/2017-State Tax (Rate) No. MGST1017/ C.R.104/Taxtaion-1, dated 29 June 2017 (collectively referred to as the Rate Notifications')
if not, whether on facts and circumstances of the case, the Unleavened Flatbreads be classified:
(i) as 'bread' as mentioned under Entry No. 97 of Notification Number 02 Number 2/2017-Integrated Tax (Rate), dated 28 June 2017, Notification Number 2/2017-Central Tax (Rate), dated 28 June 2017 and Notification Number 2/2017-State Tax (Rate) No. MGST1017/C.R.103(1)/Taxation-1 dated 29 June 2017 (collectively referred to as the 'Exemption Notifications'); or
(ii) as Malt extract, food preparations of flour, groats, meal, starch or malt extract not containi
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
he course of final hearing applicant was instructed to provide products, detailed list of ingredients, manufacturing process chart, purchase order, invoice etc. Applicant has submitted all those details. We have gone through the details as above and we find that the ingredients used to manufacture these products, the manufacturing process chart, the packaging and the storage of the products are substantially same. We find that the various ingredients used for manufacturing which are common and forming more than 80% by weight are Atta, Maida and water. The other ingredients are palmoleine oil, salt, sugar, backing powder, wheat butane etc. By resorting to this fact, applicant has laid much stress that these products are covered by the scope entry No.99A and squarely covered by the description 'khakara plane chapatti or roti' vide notification no. 34/2017 dated 13/10/2017.
Per contra the concerned officer for Revenue submitted that so far as Indian food stuffs like roti, plain roti are
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
is generally made out of refined flour and is cooked in tandoor. This roti may be called tandoori roti.
Applicant has raised question before this authority regarding classification of products such as Tortilla wraps, roti rolls, wraps, chapatti, paratha and paratha wraps.
As averted above we find no difficulty in classifying chapatti, roti and its variants as covered by scope of entry 99A of notification no. 34/2017 which covers khakara, plain chapatti or roti.
As regards Tortilla, Tortilla wraps, paratha and roti rolls revenue submitted that by common parlance test we cannot identify these product as plain roti or roti. We have examined as stated above the ingredients used for manufacturing these products, manufacturing process and the product itself. We find that these products are nothing but simple chapatti. We agree with the contention of the applicant that various types of Unleavened Flat breads are called by different names by different users depending upon the regions where
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
aratha as different and distinct food commodity from roti, chapatti etc. The product before us is examined from this view point. The product is plain like a chapatti and unstuffed like Gobhi paratha, Laccha paratha. To us, this is nothing but a plain chapatti and paratha is a misnomer for this food product supplied by the applicant. As such we do not find any difficulty in classifying the product as plain chapatti covered by entry 99A of notification no. of 34/2017.
In the light of above discussion and for the given facts that all the products contain similar/ same ingredients, manufacturing process and all the products are used as staple food item in meal we find no difficulty to arrive at a conclusion that the products are covered by entry no. 99A of notification no. 34/2017 and therefore we feel that there is no need to further deal with sub question (i), (ii) and (iii) of this question.
Que 2: “Whether on facts and circumstances of the case, the Leavened Flatbreads be treated as
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
ur good office thinks fit
In connection with the products covered by this question which are leavened Flatbreads including Naan, Kulcha, and variants of these type of Leavened breads referred internationally as pitabread, Chalupa, Cornbread, Leavened Flatbreads and unfolded Leavened Flatbreads applicant submits that similar or same manufacturing process is followed as is applicable for manufacturing of bread and therefore these product be classified as Bread within the meaning of entry no. of 97 of the exemption notification. In this regard, we find that the term mentioned above have not been defined under the Act or the notifications, we therefore refer to Dictionary or Wikipedia to understand these expressions.
Bread- Wikipedia:
Bread is a staple food prepared from a dough of flour and water usually by baking.
Bread may be leavened by processes such as reliance on naturally occurring sourdough microbes, chemicals, industrially produced yeast, or high-pressure aeration. Commercial
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
t or old kulcha dough), mixed together by hand to make a very tight dough.
In order to classify the products under a fiscal statue and in the absence of any such definition we are of the opinion that it would be a normal understanding thereof that would govern the classification of the product under issue. In a situation like one at hand we may refer to the decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of M/s. Ramawatar Budiprasad vs Assistant Sales Tax Officer, Akola reported as 12 STC 286 = 1961 (3) TMI 55 – SUPREME COURT OF INDIA.
In this judgement court adopted the following principles in the matter of construction of entries in statutes like the Sales Tax Acts:
“(1) If a statute uses the ordinary words in everyday use, such words should be construed according to their popular sense.
(2) If a word in its popular sense and read in an ordinary way is capable of two constructions, it is wise to adopt such a construction as is based on the assumption that Parliament merely intended to
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in case of M/s. Ramawatar cited supra we find that while classifying the product under fiscal statute the resort has to be to their popular meaning or meaning attached to them by those dealing in them or to their commercial sense. Viewing the above products we find that large number of consumers of this product would not regard them as roti, chapatti or as the case may be bread in the ordinary sense. It is our common experience in a restaurant or hotel that a person receiving orders specifically invite attention of the customer about whether he wants Naan, Kulcha, Roti etc. to be served with curry. In view of this we agree with the contention of the officer that by applying common parlance test, common man would not say Naan or Kulcha as a bread. Since we do not find any specific entry for products mentioned in this question and their variants they would be covered under entry no 453 of schedule III of the notification.
In spite of ours ab
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
ame name, and then deep frying the result to produce crisp, shallow corn cups. These are filled with various ingredients such as shredded chicken, pork, chopped onion, chipotle pepper, red salsa, and/or green salsa. They can in many cases resemble tostadas since both are made of a fried or baked masa based dough.
We find that normally the chalupa is a food product which are filled with various ingredients such as chicken, pork, chopped onion etc. However while arguing the matter and the sample provided to us at the time of hearing applicant has categorically submitted that they are plain products without any filling. Further from the ingredients used and the manufacturing process we do not find any similarity. In common parlance also and as discussed above chalupa is not considered as bread. And as such the product would not fall in the category of bread as covered by entry no. 97 of the exemption notification. As there is no specific entry for this product, it would be covered under
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
notification.
As per Webster dictionary the term bread has been defined as a usually baked and leavened food made of a mixture whose basic constituent is flour or meal. On the contrary as per definition and meaning given above
Pita is a yeast leavened round flatbread baked from wheat flour, sometimes with a pocket. From the ingredients and the manufacturing chart, we find that applicant uses similar/ same ingredients and same manufacturing process as that of bread. The Hon. Bombay High Court in case Commissioner of Sales Tax Vs Aggarwal and Co. (1983 (12) ELT 116) = 1982 (11) TMI 159 – BOMBAY HIGH COURT held that a general term used for any commodity in a fiscal statute covers that commodity in all its forms. As there is no difference in the conventional bread and pita bread with respect to ingredients and manufacturing process, we hold that Pitta bread would squarely fall under entry 97 of the exemption notification.
Que: 3. Whether on facts and circumstances of the case, Corn Chip
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
Exemption Notification as your good office thinks fit
As observed by us in case of other products discussed herein above we also find that the term corn chips, corn taco, corn taco strips have not been defined under the Act or notification issued. It is therefore felt necessary to refer to dictionary meaning.
Corn chips: As per Cambridge English Dictionary- Indian English a very thin slice, often round piece of fried potato or other vegetables, sometimes with a flavour added.
Corn Chips as Wikipedia – is a snack food made from cornmeal fried in oil or baked usually in the shape of a noodle or scoop.
Corn Taco- is a traditional Mexican dish consisting of a corn or wheat Tortilla folded or rolled around a filling.
It is the applicant's contention that above products are covered by the scope of expression wafer and thus classifiable under entry no.16 of schedule Ill of the rate notification dated 28/06/2017.
The term “wafers” has been defined as per Webster Dictionary as a “thin cr
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
izza bread, khakhra, plain chapatti or roti, bread, rusks, toasted bread and similar toasted products
BREAD, PASTRY, CAKES, BISCUITS AND OTHER BAKERS' WARES, WHETHER OR NOT CONTAINING COCOA; COMMUNION WAFERS, EMPTY CACHETS OF KIND SUITABLE FOR PHARMACEU TICAL USE, SEALING WAFERS, RICE PAPER AND SIMILAR PRODUCTS
1905
BREAD , PASTRY, CAKES, BISCUITS AND OTHER BAKERS' WARES, WHETHER OR NOT CONTAINING COCOA; COMMUNION WAFERS, EMPTY CACHETS OF A KIND SUITABLE FOR PHARMACEUTICAL USE, SEALING WAFERS, RICE PAPER AND SIMILAR PRODUCTS
19051000
–
Crispbread
19052000
–
Gingerbread and the like
–
Sweet biscuits; waffers and wafers:
19053100
Sweet biscuits
190532
Waffles and wafers :
Communion wafers :
19053211
–
Coated with chocolate or containing chocolate
19053219
–
Other
19053290
Other
19054000
–
Rusks, toasted bread and similar toasted products
190590
–
Other :
19059010
Pastries and cakes
19059020
Bisc
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
uits; Pastries and cakes (other than pizza bread, khakhra, plain chapatti or roti, Waffles and wafers coated with chocolate or containing chocolate, papad, bread) as mentioned under Entry No. 16 of Schedule III of Rate Notifications.
If not, whether on facts and circumstances of the case, the Pancakes be classified in any other Schedule Entry as per Rate Notification or Exemption Notification as your good office thinks fit
Pan cakes:
This term is also not defined under the act and therefore we refer to Wikipedia which defines the term as below:
'Pancakes', is a flat cake, often thin and round, prepared from a starch-based batter that may contain milk baked on a hot surface such as a griddle or frying pan.
The pancakes are manufactured by using ingredients like wheat flour, water, sugar, salt, milk, syrup, oil etc. Similarly we find that cake is an item soft sweet food made from a mixture of flour, fat, eggs, sugar, and other ingredients, baked and sometimes iced and decorated.
T
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
on facts and circumstances of the case, Pizza Base supplied be treated as 'Pizza Bread' as mentioned under Entry No. 99 of Schedule / of Rate Notifications.
If not, whether on facts and circumstances of the case, the Pizza Base be classified in any other Schedule Entry as per Rate Notification or Exemption Notification as your good office thinks fit
The products are manufactured by the Applicant i.e. pizza base using various ingredients including flour, water, sugar, salt, baking powder, yeast, oil etc. After raw material intake, the ingredients go through various processes including mixing, proofing, dough dividing, baking and cooling. As per entry number 99 of Schedule I to the Central Rate Notifications, the product description is 'pizza bread'. Having regard to the ratio of the judgement in case of Aggarwal and Company cited supra the schedule entry for pizza bread is wide enough to cover pizza base within its ambit. The Pizza base is required for manufacture of Pizza. It
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
te Tax (Rate) No. MGST1017/ C.R. 104/Taxation-1, dated 29 June 2017 (collectively referred to as the 'Rate Notifications')
If not, whether on facts and circumstances of the case, the Unleavened Flatbreads be classified:
(i) as 'bread' as mentioned under Entry No. 97 of Notification Number 02 Number 2/2017-Integrated Tax (Rate), dated 28 June 2017, Notification Number 2/2017-CentraI Tax (Rate), dated 28 June 2017 and Notification Number 2/2017-State Tax (Rate) No. MGST1017/C.R. 103(1)/Taxation-1, dated 29 June 2017 (collectively referred to as the 'Exemption Notifications'); or
(ii) as Malt extract, food preparations of flour, groats, meal, starch or malt extract not containing coca or containing less than 40% by weight of coca calculated on a totally defatted basis, not elsewhere specified or included [other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905]on a totally defatted bas
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
r
(ii) as Malt extract, food preparations of flour, groats, meal, starch or malt extract not containing coca or containing less than 40% by weight of coca calculated on a totally defatted basis, not elsewhere specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905]on a totally defatted basis not elsewhere specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers' wares of heading 1905) under Entry No. 13 of Schedule III of Rate Notification or
(i) Any other Schedule Entry as per Rate Notification or Exemption Notification as your good office thinks fit
Answer :- The product Leavened Flatbreads stated in application such as Naan, Kulcha and Chalupa are not covered by the expression 'bread' as mentioned under Entry No. 97 of Exemption Notifications but they would be covered u
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
re specified or included (other than preparations for infants or young children, put up for retail sale and mixes and doughs for the preparation of bakers ' wares of heading 1905)” under Entry No. 13 of Schedule III of Rate Notification; or
(ii) Any other Schedule Entry as per Rate Notification or Exemption Notification as your good office thinks fit
Answer :- The products like Corn Chips, Corn Taco and Corn , Taco Strips would be treated as 'wafer' under Entry No. 16 of Schedule III of Rate Notifications and it would be liable for taxes @ 18 9% CGST and 9% MGST
Question 4:- “Whether on facts and circumstances of the case, Pancakes supplied be treated as All Goods i.e. Waffles and wafers other than coated with chocolate or containing chocolate; biscuits; Pastries and cakes (other than pizza bread, khakhra, plain chapatti or roti, Waffles and wafers coated with chocolate or containing chocolate, papad, bread) as mentioned under Entry No. 16 of Schedule Ill ofRate Notifications.
If n
= = = = = = = =
Plain text (Extract) only
For full text:-Visit the Source
= = = = = = = =
